Since jewellery helps us stand out from the crowd, why not choose the bold, natural allure of turquoise? Zirconia’s brilliance is also interesting, so you must wear this gemstone in a special dress. But let’s see the ways turquoise jewellery different from zirconia jewellery.

It might surprise you to discover the contrasts between turquoise and zirconia go beyond color and sparkle. While turquoise is a naturally occurring gemstone with vibrant hues and historical significance, zirconia is a man-made crystal resembling a diamond. From the origins of these stones to their symbolism, the two are quite distinct.

If you wonder which of the gemstones mentioned above is more suitable for a special occasion, keep on reading. I will investigate the 10 ways these two striking types of jewellery are not the same. Some of their variations might surprise you.

10 Ways Turquoise Jewellery Different From Zirconia Jewellery

I have knowledge about different gemstones, so let me guide you further. We will explore together the 10 ways turquoise jewellery is different from zirconia jewellery:

1. Natural vs. Synthetic

A big difference between turquoise and zirconia jewellery is in origin, which can be natural or synthetic. Turquoise comes from Nature and forms over millions of years in arid regions from minerals like aluminum and copper. It has unique blue-green hues and a one-of-a-kind look.

On the other hand, zirconia is synthetic and created in laboratories to mimic the sparkle of diamonds. Cubic zirconia has stunning brilliance and is more affordable, lacking natural history and organic imperfections. All cultures cherish both these gemstones for their beauty and appreciate the fact that they’re affordable.

Aside from origins, the natural vs. synthetic distinction affects the overall aesthetic and value of these gemstones. Turquoise is formed organically and results in unique patterns and shades. On the other hand, zirconia is created in the lab, offering perfect clarity and consistency.

2. Color

As far as color goes, turquoise and zirconia jewellery offer vastly different aesthetics. For instance, little girls appreciate turquoise for its stunning blue-to-green hues. Each gem of this kind is unique and often features veins of matrix that give it more natural beauty and character.

Turquoise is very popular in bohemian, Southwestern, tribal-inspired designs because it has vibrant, earthy tones. Zirconia and especially cubic zirconia don’t have any color so they’re clear and resemble a diamond. However, humans manufacture it in different colors, from deep reds to blues and bright yellows.

Despite variety, the appeal of zirconia is often rooted in its diamond-like sparkle and brilliance, so not in its color diversity. Turquoise has natural and rich hues, so it evokes earthy elegance. On the other hand, zirconia offers a more modern and polished look with dazzling clarity and customizable color options.

3. Origin

When it comes to origins, turquoise and zirconia jewellery are also different and distinguishing. Turquoise occurs in Nature, when water interacts with copper and other minerals. Some of the major sources of this gemstone are in Tibet, Iran, Southwestern United States, and Egypt.

In Egyptian, Native American, and Persian civilizations, turquoise symbolizes spiritual power, protection, and healing. However, zirconia is man-made and produced in laboratories using a chemical process. Its most common form is cubic zirconia, which was developed as an alternative to diamonds.  

Different from turquoise, zirconia’s synthetic origins allow for perfection and precision as far as clarity and brilliance go. The natural formation of turquoise contrasts sharply with the modern, lab-created origins of zirconia. What you should know is that each of these stones has a different appeal and significance.

4. Symbolism

Turquoise is more than just a decorative gemstone, as it carries deep spiritual and cultural symbolism. In the Egyptian, Persian, and Native American cultures, this stone was used to ward off negative energy. Some people worked with it to bring them good fortune.

But what’s most important to know is that turquoise represents spiritual balance, healing, and communication. This gemstone is one of the most popular for those who seek a deeper connection with their inner selves. You can buy turquoise jewellery from the online Red Lily shop for your daughter to learn more about her personality.

While this blue gemstone offers a meaningful connection to ancient traditions, zirconia is more appealing to those who seek sparkle and style. If you are an Aussie grandparent, you could get your granddaughter zirconia jewellery that goes with special attires. She could wear the piece you have given her to a classy party with her most elegant dress suitable for her age.

5. Hardness

Another key distinction between these two gemstones is their hardness. Turquoise is relatively soft and ranks around 5-6 on the Mohs hardness scale. Being soft, it’s more prone to scratches, general wear, and chipping, so you should pay more attention to it. 

Despite being low in hardness, turquoise is still appreciated for its natural beauty. However, it’s best suited for pieces that aren’t subjected to rough wear. Your daughter or granddaughter could wear turquoise jewellery at a fairy party with a blue dress.

In contrast, zirconia and particularly cubic zirconia is significantly harder. It scores 8-8.5 on the Mohs scale, so it’s more resistant and durable to damage and scratches. For this reason, zirconia is ideal for everyday jewellery such as bracelets that don’t lose their sparkle.

6. Cost

Another major factor that differentiates turquoise jewellery from the zirconia one is cost. Since turquoise occurs in Nature, its value varies widely depending on origin, quality, and color. High-grade turquoise such as the one from the Sleeping Beauty Mine in Arizona or Persia is quite expensive.

Natural turquoise usually costs more because it’s unique and the highest-quality pieces are free from inclusions or matrix. People appreciate this gemstone for its history and natural beauty. You can buy jewellery with turquoise for your daughter from the Red Lily shop.

On the other hand, zirconia and especially cubic zirconia is much more affordable. This synthetic gemstone is mass-produced in laboratories, at low costs. Your granddaughter will surely appreciate jewellery made with it, especially if it’s bought from the socially responsible Red Lily online shop.

7. Clarity And Sparkle         

Other notable ways in which turquoise and zirconia jewellery differ are clarity and sparkle. Turquoise is an opaque gemstone with a matte finish. Its natural formation includes variations in texture and color, and the gemstone has a distinct matrix of inclusions or veins.

Since it has a unique appearance, turquoise is one of the most charming gemstones. However, it’s less brilliant and sparkling compared to transparent stones. Pieces with turquoise stones are valuable because they easily catch the attention of those who see the person who wears them.

Zirconia and especially cubic zirconia are renowned for their exceptional brilliance and clarity. Since it’s a synthetic gemstone, humans crafted zirconia to achieve near-perfect transparency and intense sparkle. Zirconia also has a high refractive index that reflects light with dazzling intensity, creating a visually striking effect.

8. Durability

Another important difference between turquoise and zirconia jewellery is durability. Turquoise is relatively porous and soft. Therefore, it’s easier to scratch and damage it, especially if you expose it to oils, harsh chemicals, or direct sunlight for a long time.

You should handle and maintain turquoise jewellery more carefully, especially if you want to preserve its beauty. This gemstone is suitable for occasional spring wear, particularly in pieces like earrings or pendants. Usually, turquoise stones don’t go through much wear and tear.

Zirconia and cubic zirconia are much more durable stones. They are resistant to damage and scratches, so perfect for everyday wear. Another great thing about these types of stones is that they can handle regular exposure to environmental factors.

9. Cultural Significance

When it comes to cultural significance, turquoise, and zirconia jewellery are very different in their symbolic and historical values. Various ancient civilizations have been revering turquoise for thousands of years. In Native American culture, turquoise is regarded as sacred.

This gemstone has been highly prized in ancient Persia and Egypt too. Here, it represented power, good fortune, and status. Turquoise is often regarded as of the earth because it’s believed to connect its wearer to Nature.

Zirconia doesn’t have such a rich cultural history. It is only a synthetic gemstone developed in the 20^th century. People admire it for its beauty and brilliance, as it doesn’t carry any spiritual or historical significance. The appeal of zirconia is rather in its aesthetics and affordability rather than in its symbolic or cultural connection.

10. Care

Lastly, another important aspect where turquoise and zirconia jewellery differ significantly is care. Since I have mentioned that turquoise is soft, you should understand that it requires delicate handling. It’s very easy to scratch or damage its surface, especially if you expose it to perfumes and even sweat.

Turquoise can lose its vibrant color after exposure. In other words, you should store jewellery made with this stone carefully and clean it with a soft, damp cloth. Don’t wear it during activities where it might be exposed to increased moisture or chemicals.

The good news is that it’s easier to care for zirconia jewellery. Since it’s synthetic in nature and harder, this gemstone is also more resistant to damage and scratches. You can even clean it with soap and water without risking damaging it.

Main Differences Between Turquoise Jewellery And Zirconia Jewellery

Since I know a lot about turquoise and zirconia gemstones, I also understand the main differences between these types of jewellery. For this reason, I have put together a table that highlights them:

Turquoise	Zirconia
Natural gemstone, formed over millions of years	Synthetic, lab-created stone, designed to mimic diamonds
Opaque with unique blue-green hues and natural patterns (often with matrix veins)	Clear and colorless, resembling diamonds, but available in various manufactured colors
Rich cultural significance, associated with protection, healing, and spiritual power	Primarily valued for its sparkle, with no deep historical or cultural symbolism

Conclusion

Turquoise and zirconia jewellery have distinct characteristics, each appealing to different tastes and preferences. Turquoise is natural and beautiful, bearing cultural significance, so it’s perfect for people who appreciate history and unique pieces. But since it’s soft, it requires more careful handling. Zirconia stands out from the crowd because it’s durable, affordable, and practical. If you understand the key differences between the two, you also understand which suits your daughter’s style best.